Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Stephanie Meyer

This a secondary post to the one above, even though I wrote it later.
Because I got myself all worked up.
And I didn't discuss fully how terrible a person and writer I think Stephanie Meyer is.
And I want to.
Because of my over powering angst.

I would like to address all of my problems with Stephanie Meyer separately, beginning of course, with the most common complaint of her:

She is a terrible writer: She does not obey any grammatical laws. She is repetitive and obnoxious. The story lines in every single one of her books begins 2/3rds of the way through, instead of, you know, at the beginning. Except of course, her last novel, in which the entire story arch is completely closed at the beginning when Bella and Edward FINALLY have sex, since that's all the books were leading up to. Then an entirely NEW plot randomly begins and Bella has a monster baby. This, of course, is completely unrelated to the previous books.

She is a terrible person: I honestly believe that you should try to convey your values in your literature. NO, I don't think that mean you have to write only Mormon books if you are Mormon. However, I cannot help but feel that all of her books are PRO-abortion and PRO-pre-martial sex. I would not even care about this, except that everyone in the world knows that she graduated from BYU.
An author came to talk to us once and said "Stephanie Meyer has done something great. Her first books were all against having sex before marriage and her last book was anti-abortion."
If you remember the first books, all Bella wants to do is bang her undead stalker. He will not let her because he doesn't want to go to hell. They fight about it all the time. She begs him repeatedly to please prove how much he loves her by doing the dirty. He keeps saying no. She is constantly depressed and angry because of it. Finally they decide to get married so that they can have sex without feeling guilty. Please do not tell me that story line is ANTI pre-martial sex.

Then in the last book, after finally getting married and doing it ONCE, Bella is knocked up with a creature like unto those from scary alien books. It eats her from the inside. Everyone around her wants to kill the baby because they think it is evil. Bella becomes crazed. She decided to let it live literally off her blood. It rips itself a hole in her stomach and crawls on out, leaving Bella to die. Psych, suddenly Bella is a vampire. Yay!
Stephanie Meyer should be embarrassed. I think somewhere she probably is.
Deep down, you know.

She has deprived an entire generation of happy relationships: Yes. Even on campus, where these people should be ADULTS, I have heard men say "I decided to read Twilight so girls will like me more."
I have heard women say "I asked my boyfriend to read Twilight so he could understand my needs better."
This is what men will learn: Be better looking. Hang out with girls with low self-esteem, but who are secretly hot. Creep into her bedroom at night to watch her sleep. Wear lip gloss. Follow her around and spy on her, even before you have officially become friends. What she thinks is not important, it is all about how she smells/looks. Protect her from things, she is helpless and easily confused. Deny her of any physical affection and she'll only want you more. Beat up other boys who like her and then be mean about it. Abandon her whenever and if you come back she will accept you, as most victims of abusive relationships do.

This is what women will learn: My personality is unimportant, as long as I am attractive. I should let men do things for me because if I do things for myself he does not love me. Stalking is not creepy, it is romantic. If I somehow make an attractive person love me I should do really nice things for him all the time and cry all the time because I do not deserve him. Love, lust, and obsession are all the same thing. If a man leaves me, I should kill myself. If I fail to kill myself before his return, I should take him back. He left me because he loves me. I should try to date as many men as possible, because I am ugly and clumsy and stupid. If I trick my man into doing me I will be happy and assured of his love.

(I'm not really done, but I have to rush to class, so that is all for now.)

9 comments:

tammy said...

Perfectly put!!!! Seriously I am going to link people to this post. Good job.

Lana said...

Amen.

sweetheber said...

Amen!!! Seriously, what is wrong with these women?

brooke said...

i hate her and her books so much i could punch her all the way to edward's pancreas and it wouldn't be enough to tell her how i feel.

Allie said...

touche. i didn't make it past the first book, but it sounds like i didn't miss much.

Mary said...

I smiled the whole time I read this, I will not lie I enjoyed reading the books, but while reading them I understood her grammatical errors and found some of Edward's characteristics a little on the creepy side. My husband will not be like edward.

kaylie jean. said...

haha, then why did you finish them? i stopped at one.

katie might hate you after this post.

i don't hate stephanie meyer. and i obviously don't love twilight. but if we're going to be critical of mormon authors, have you read orson scott card? he's got some messed up stuff. stuff like shifting trans-gender humanoids, sexual abuse, murder, etc.

but he's certainly not a bad person. and even if he were, i would never begin to judge him so eagerly, openly, and ignorantly.

i refer you to this article:
http://www.writing-world.com/sf/card.shtml

and you asked for opinions...

mine?
stephanie meyer might be a bad writer, but she's also a person. i think she deserves a break.

Katie said...

I agree with Kaylie

tammy said...

I do not agree with Kaylie. Writing books for the public to read opens yourself up to public opinion good or bad. If you don't like criticism then don't put yourself out there. Stephanie does not deserve a break. She should learn from her mistakes just like everyone else. She is not a bad person just a silly one who sold her smut for money so she is a little smart too.